Playtest Record
This is the one running record of every playtest on Shady Shipping, from the prototype sessions in October to the latest uni test. Each row says who played, what they found and what we changed because of it. Together the rows show the game being shaped by play, not only by plan: almost every system in the game changed at least once because someone drove it and told us what was wrong.
Abdullah ran the playtests and wrote up the feedback, and he drove nearly every build himself before it was checked in. Where a list was typed up by someone else, the finding is still credited to the person who played. This follows the playcentric approach in Fullerton (2019): build, play, listen and change, in short loops.
How to read the table. "Uni" means the university labs, with the dedicated server (a PC that only runs the game for everyone else) on Abdullah's home PC unless the row says otherwise. "Sandbox" is the test copy of the project. Several findings from one session have one row each, so every cell stays short. New playtests add rows at the bottom.
| Date | Who played | Where | What they found | What we changed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 to 11 Oct | The team (prototype) | Uni, separate PCs | Traffic and the bumper net worked online | Recorded as tested online, correcting the plan |
| 10 to 11 Oct | The team (prototype) | Uni, separate PCs | The game crashed when a car hit scaffolding online | A suspension setting on every build; "tested online" now means separate PCs |
| 21 Oct | Abdullah and lab PCs | Uni, phone hotspot to home server | No PC could connect at first | The server PC now opens the port on the router itself |
| 21 Oct | Abdullah and lab PCs | Uni, phone hotspot to home server | Play worked at 50 to 73 ms ping with no packet loss | One hotspot carries two or three PCs; update PCs before switching |
| 26 Oct | Abdullah (Dafydd typed the list) | Sandbox city | Far cars vanished; look-back slid over the roof | Every car always sent; no camera lag looking back |
| 26 Oct | Abdullah | Sandbox city | Kerbs hit like walls and cost health | Ball-shaped wheel checks, firmer van springs, no damage from low steps |
| 26 Oct | Abdullah | Sandbox city | Wrecks kept clean wheels; auto-reset got stuck; garage door caught the van | Burnt wheels, a safer reset point, the van lined up on the door |
| 26 Oct | Abdullah | Sandbox city | The police car stuttered at lower frame rates | Recorded frame by frame; the city speed-up keeps frames fast |
| 26 Oct | Abdullah | Sandbox | The new hologram radar was hard to read | A readability pass: "much better" |
| 27 Oct | Abdullah, three players | Sandbox, one PC | A police player saw another player's radar | Each player draws their own radar |
| 27 Oct | Abdullah | Sandbox | The police could see the van nearly all the time | The police get sightings only, through a view cone |
| 27 Oct | Abdullah | Sandbox | Parcel beam faint, pay-out flat, sparkles in the camera | Brighter beam, new pay-out stings, sparkles thrown sideways |
| 27 Oct | Abdullah | Sandbox | A damaged courier with a parcel never saw the garage route | Job route and faint garage route shown together |
| 27 Oct | Abdullah, by ear | Sandbox | Landings sounded like one thud; the police car sounded weaker than the van | Four messy landing takes; a turbo six-cylinder police engine |
| 28 Oct | Host and one client | One PC, networked | The next round started with no courier for 10 s | The host waits for returning players, up to 30 s |
| 29 Oct | Abdullah | Dafydd's city map | Flat grey light, radar cut off streets, bumps at every T-junction | Golden hour light, whole-city radar, junctions fixed in the road pack |
| 30 Oct | Abdullah's session, lab PCs and laptops | Uni, phone hotspot | Pickups and drop-offs looked alike; Abdullah wanted the route on the road | Colour and motion coding; arrows on the road to the job |
| 30 Oct | Abdullah's session | Uni, phone hotspot | Cops followed the van into the garage and shoved it back in | An unseen wall across the garage doorway |
| 30 Oct | Abdullah's session | Uni, phone hotspot | A wrecked cop kept the van netted across the map | A wrecked cop lets go at once |
| 30 Oct | Abdullah's session | Uni, phone hotspot | Cops nearby kept the garage shut; the police car turned too slowly | The garage opens with cops near; sharper police steering |
| 30 Oct | Abdullah's session | Uni, phone hotspot | Bigger map, no compass, a tougher-looking van | Passed to Dafydd, Ieuan and the artist |
| Late Oct | Lecturers | Course review | The world looked grey next to the arcade UI | The city recoloured to a sunset pastel palette |
| 1 Nov | Abdullah, up to five players | Sandbox lobby | Loading lifted onto a random spot; he saw other players' intros | A cover until each player's own intro |
| 1 Nov | Abdullah | Sandbox lobby | Nobody would find the garage camera; the car park felt cramped | Drag and zoom hints; ceiling raised to 4.8 m |
| 2 Nov | Abdullah, two players | Team project | The waiting screen showed through the cover; GO hung on 1 | Cover on the top layer; GO shown by each screen's clock |
| 2 Nov | Abdullah and two lab PCs, five rounds | Uni, through the lobby | The lobby worked with every player on their own PC | No change needed |
| 2 Nov | Abdullah and two lab PCs | Uni | Stops felt slow; a ditch cost too much time | Faster loading and unloading; shorter wait after a ditch |
| 2 Nov | Abdullah and two lab PCs | Uni | Fire warned too late before a wreck | Engines catch fire at 50% health, not 20% |
| 3 Nov | Abdullah | Police garage | The splitter overlapped the exhausts; flashing lights hid the paint | Pipes-only exhausts; the light bar stays dark in the garage |
| 5 Nov | Abdullah | Police garage | Icons looked the same, photos cheap, the shortfall read as a price | Locator sticker icons, part cut-outs, struck price with the shortfall |
| Oct to Nov | Lecturers | Course reviews | Why do the police chase a delivery van? | The van's dodgy look: armour, bullet holes, blacked-out windows |
| 6 Nov | Abdullah | Van garage | Kit parts hovered, clipped or stayed level in corners | Every part fixed; parts lean with the body |
| 7 Nov | Abdullah | Garages | Parts sat behind the menus; paint was hard to see; stickers looked like bugs | New camera rule; neutral stage light; stickers and stripes removed |
| 9 Nov | Uni playtest | Uni, home server | The new city map would not load | The previous map restored |
| 9 Nov | Uni playtest | Uni, home server | Players fell back to the default map after the lobby | Players wait up to 90 s for the city |
| 9 Nov | Uni playtest | Uni, home server | Every crash froze the game, worst on slower PCs | Dents worked out in the background; a lighter police model |
| 9 Nov | Uni playtest | Uni, home server | The van sometimes hung off its wheels at the start | A car with a driver is never left asleep |
| 9 Nov | Lecturers | Uni playtest | The police gained nothing when the van stopped at a bay | Arrests, three strikes and the drop-in |
| 9 Nov | Ieuan | Uni playtest | The round timer felt redundant | Strikes replaced the shift clock |
| 9 Nov | Uni playtest | Uni, home server | Players could not afford to try the garage | Every wallet topped up to £100,000 for testing |
| 10 Nov | Abdullah and two lab PCs | Uni, phone tethered to a switch | Both lab PCs joined the home server over mobile data | Replaces the Wi-Fi hotspot for uni tests |
| 10 Nov | Abdullah | Uni lab PC as host | A lab PC cannot host: the uni firewall blocks every incoming join | A personal laptop must host on the switch |
| 10 Nov | Two-PC test | Two PCs, networked | A slower PC started late and missed the drive-in | The round waits until every PC runs smoothly |
| 10 Nov | Abdullah, two players | Sandbox | Strike cutscenes work from both sides; clamp and lift shots need work | Open: see the abilities chapter |
What the record shows
| Pattern | Example |
|---|---|
| Most fixes landed the same day | All six bugs from the 26 Oct playtest were fixed and checked in that day |
| Uni tests found what one PC never did | Load times, firewalls, slow PCs and the crash stutter |
| Outside players found design gaps | The lecturers' questions led to the van's look and to arrests |
| Feel was tuned by playing, not by numbers | Landings, smoke, the hologram radar and the garage all changed after Abdullah drove them |