Shady Shipping Wiki Underdog Studios
Under the hood

Balance

An asymmetric game is only fair if both sides win about as often, whatever the number of cops. This chapter sets the targets and the dials Dafydd uses to reach them.

Live tuning: a sheet edit reaches every player in seconds, and unsafe values are refused
Live tuning: a sheet edit reaches every player in seconds, and unsafe values are refused
From the tuning sheet to the systems that use each value
From the tuning sheet to the systems that use each value

The targets

MeasureTargetWhy
Van win rate45% to 55% at every cop countNeither side should feel the game is rigged
Round length4 to 6 minutesShort enough to play many rounds in a session
Strikes per roundAt least one in most roundsThe police must feel they can catch the van
EscapesThe van escapes in about half of roundsEscaping must feel possible, never certain

The dials

Each dial is one value on the tuning sheet. The table says what turning it up does.

DialTurn it up andHelps
Strikes until the police winRounds run longer; the van gets more chancesVan
Deliveries for the first starExits open laterPolice
Exits that openMore escape routes to guardVan
Arrest timeCops need longer to box the van inVan
Ring sizeEasier to arrest from further awayPolice
Search circle sizePolice know less about where an illegal van isVan
Time before an idle van is searchedHiding lasts longerVan
Ability cooldownsFewer uses per round for that sideThe other side

Scaling with the number of cops

More cops make the police stronger in a chase. The dials above can be set per cop count, so the game stays fair from one cop to four. The pre-production model balanced a cash target against the cop count; that target was retired when strikes replaced the clock, and balance is now checked by playing.

CopsExpected effectFirst dial to try
1Hard for one cop to box the van inShorter arrest time
2The intended team sizeNone
3 to 4Easy to surround the vanLonger arrest time, or a fourth strike

How balance is checked

StepWhoWhen
Play rounds at each cop countThe teamEach playtest session
Record winner, strikes and round lengthThe host's database, automaticallyEvery round
Change one dial at a time on the sheetDafyddBetween rounds
Log the change and the reasonDafyddIn the sheet's change log